How to assess product design skills

Portfolio review

Design process: how it looks in portfolio vs how it actually happened
Design process: how it looks in portfolio vs how it actually happened
  • Still the best way to assess visual design
  • The least time-consuming for a hiring manager
  • It is the most time-consuming for candidates, and, not surprisingly, more senior candidates refuse to spend time on it.
  • Though supposedly it reflects real-life experiences, it’s impossible to say what actually happened. People rarely take credit for things they didn’t do, but it is tempting and honestly more practical¹ to show polished design concepts rather than the real-life product that went through all the challenges of dealing with stakeholders, timelines, and technical limitations.
  • It gives an advantage to candidates who were better placed in previous jobs (e.g., someone working on a product from scratch will be struggling to showcase their usage of quantitative data)

Whiteboard challenge

  • Allows to see how the candidate thinks, real-time
  • Works well to assess personality and teamwork
  • The least time commitment from the candidate as they’ll be guaranteed to spend determined upfront couple hours.
  • Though it’s good to evaluate design thinking and generativity, assessing other skills is difficult: from the inability to assess UI design almost entirely to a very speculative evaluation of other skills (“I would talk to customers,” everybody says)
  • Not exactly representative of a designer’s day-to-day job. How often do you really have to come up with a solution on the spot while being watched by people and reasonably stressed?

Design challenge (take-home task)

  • It can be designed to assess the most important skills.
  • Gives candidates time to think and research and the ability to demonstrate their approach.
  • Most of the time, it’s impossible to timebox, so candidates who are eager to spend more time will get an advantage.
  • Some companies see this as an opportunity to get people to work for free. Not surprisingly, candidates who’ve had these experiences consider any design challenge evil and refuse to participate.
  • Unethical behavior of some companies gets way more attention than the fact that quite a few candidates would enjoy take-home tasks more than working on their portfolio as an opportunity to learn something new.

--

--

--

Product, data, decision-making, philosophy| Learning from everything that went wrong | Digital Product Designer | elenaborisova.com

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Out with Commitment, in with Enrichment

From being a design newbie to landing my first internship & gig

Breathing new life into the ICO Workshops

MICHAELANGELO OR BOB THE BUILDER: WHO YOU SHOULD CALL TO BUILD YOUR WEBSITE

#5: Weather and Email Receipt

Color Theory: Heat Maps use color temperature to convey information quickly.

6 Tips for Outdoor Fashion Photography

Mapping the “design” discipline to build a learning architecture

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Elena Borisova

Elena Borisova

Product, data, decision-making, philosophy| Learning from everything that went wrong | Digital Product Designer | elenaborisova.com

More from Medium

The five stages of being the first UX designer at a product company

Title

Facilitating a Design Jam step-by-step

The design assembly line

Three shapes in a line, one of them walking and leaving the line

The UX of Boredom (Week 2–3)/ UX Studio Practices

Partially Blurred Faces — The outcome of the “Reflective mirror” concept